Dating Game Mafia - GAME OVER!

[Courk]

Vote count:

MattV - 2 - (Mackay, Mgm)

Mgm - 1 - (MattV)

[ralphmerridew]

On MGM's claim:

1) I have believed since the beginning that the bachlorette would be a role.
2) Mgm says that Logain investigated crackerjack twice, both before the replacement. (It's possible that Logain simply forgot who he'd investigated (unlikely) or was rechecking now that the recruiter was dead.)
3) 3.5 information roles seems a bit much for a game of this size. (Though Courk was generous in Clue Mafia.)

[Mgm]

<s></s> were indeed strikeout tags. Why aren't they working?

[Mgm]

[Dragon Phoenix]

<> tags do not work on this site, you need to use [ ].

I need to re-read the thread, but that will be earliest Sunday (I'm flying back today).

[ralphmerridew]

[Mgm]

Noted. I changed the "ralphm" result to "ralphm2" to make things clearer, because I thought you were a replacement already when you were investigated... My guess is that all those replacements confused Logain as well.

[Mackay]

Holy Crap!, Mgm. I trust you more than anyone else at the moment. Your claim seems valid, your results (the ones I can tell) seem valid.

I remember people thinking there was a bachelorette to begin with. Why...? Because there was a bachelorette in the .gif at the beginning of the game, and in the introduction.
However, there is no mention of a host whatsoever. Not even a hint that one might exist. DP still registers high on my scum-o-meter, and now he comes out with a claim that is 'important', but in no way provable. I don't like it. My vote is staying on MattV, I am pretty convinced mattv is scum. But a good old-fashioned Courk-esque IGMEOY goes to DP.

[MatthewV]

I honestly thought that he was using <s> and </s> to denote suspicion. That was the main source of my lack of confidence; it basically he lied directly.

I am not convince yet that his role is good for the town though. Seems it could logically go either way.

unvote mgm

Is there anything about my being suspicious to highlight for explaination?

[Mackay]

Suggesting killing off jadesmar? Claiming you were doing it to stir up the town only? Resisting with all your might the claiming of numbers? Which you still haven't done? Voting Mgm "with confidence" upon finding out that he allegedly had cop results? Claiming that once again you were "irking" the town for results?

It almost looks like you are covering for DP.

[Mackay]

I'd better explain that. The scumminess/suicidalness of your posts seems to be directly proportional to the amount of suspicion that is on DP at the time. If I thought the two of you were in it together, which I do, I'd be inclined to believe you were covering for him. Or at least trying to take off the heat.

Or maybe you're just suicidal today. I am only too happy to oblige a suicidal scum. Confirm vote: MattV

[MatthewV]

[MatthewV]

Oh, I was meaning to remove that quote from Mackay at the start of the last post. I was referring directly toward it, but it wasn't supposed to be there. /wishes he could edit

[Dragon Phoenix]

[Dragon Phoenix]

BTW, that's 3 out of 4.

[Mackay]

Given the set-up? Apparently you know more than I do, DP.

What does the host DO? Or did you tell us already, and I forgot?

In any case, it's unlikely that there are two special roles, plus a doctor remaining. The only person who convinces me is Mgm, though it's probably dangerous to vote off MattV if he's claiming doc...

sadly, the thing that keeps me voting for him right now is the fact that I'm edgy about DP's allegiation that we're supporting each other. Plus I still reckon he's scum.

[Mgm]

I can't remember MattV claiming doc, but if he did, I'm even happier with lynching him. We already had several docs die. Including myself in my previous life. And investigator Logain wasn't protected the night he died. So, I don't think there's any docs left. If there were, Logain would've been with us now.

[Mgm]

[Mackay]

That was the impression I got...?

[MatthewV]

It should be noted that the two dead doctors are numbered 84 and 42...logic here?

Yes, I am #21 a doctor. I have asked and I cannot save myself. Thus tonight it seems likely I will die.

I am sorry I let Logain die after he was saved once. (I became a replacement after he was saved.) I didn't believe they would target him after missing one shot.

DP- that vote was +very+ dangerous...care to explain more?

[Mackay]

Multiples of 21...?

Bachelor number 63 was a townie.

Scalawag!

[Mackay]

Is there any indication that there are more cops? Are there usually more cops than docs? 2 cops dead, 2 docs dead...

Sorry, Matt, but I can't believe at this point in time that you are innocent. (Scalawag)

[MatthewV]

84/2=42, 42/2=21
cozy little pattern...

I would have the same troubles in believing you and DP are innocent also.

[Mackay]

Yes, well I didn't claim to be another special role in a game nearing its end. I saw the number pattern in the doubling also, but can't believe that number 63 would be there also, if that were the case.

Who'd you protect, matt?

[MatthewV]

night 1...IS
night 2...Mgm
night 3...Porro
night 4...Logain (no death!)
<MatthewV takes over>
night 5...Neo
night 6...Mackay

Right...night 5 was Neo. The mindset was that IF the cult could kill at night they would do so. AND that it appears he has some sort of extra infomation, making him a choice for the mafia also. AND that losing another kill on Logain would be foolish.

Night 6 I though Mackay would die. She made some comments about people I also felt were evil at the time. Her death seemed logical just to shut her mouth!

Who will be my night 7 choice? Dunno, I usually focus on one little thing that might prompt a kill.

I am not really trying to save myself anymore- death either today or tonight is -very- likely. But I would like to see a night kill wasted on me.

[MatthewV]

"wasted" isn't the best word choice for my third to last word :P

[Neo]

Mackay, where are you getting 63?
_________________
_{Ad Astra}

[Mackay]

[Mgm]

I've done some more checking and now I'm even more suspicious of MatthewV. I died on night 1 in my doc role and only replaced after night 3. So, how exactly could MatthewV have protected me night 2?

Confirm vote: MatthewV

[Courk]

Vote count:

MattV - 3 - (Mackay, Mgm, DP)

[ralphmerridew]

I already said that I have my own reasons for believing DP to be good.
I've said I have my reasons for believing that the bachlorette is in the game, so I'm inclined to believe Mgm.
Mackay is cleared of being cult or thug by Mgm, so I'm inclined to trust her.
All of them agree that MatthewV is suspicious.

I also think that 3 docs is too much, that any doc who didn't protect Logain would be stupid, and that the "Mgm" slipup is pretty damaging.

Therefore, when all the factors align that well, Vote: MatthewV

[Courk]

And with that, MattV is lynched. Congratulations! You have killed bachelor #2. He also just happened to be mafia - but not just any mafia, he was the Godfather.

All night choices are due Wednesday, Oct. 27 at 2:00 pm EST.

[MatthewV]

All the replacements are really starting ot confuse me...

*dies*

[Courk]

I hate having to do this, but I couldn't go on indefinitely waiting for replacements. Although Jedo and mudbuck have been in the cult, they were just about the only people to volunteer as replacements (besides verbose, but that's only one person). I have decided to let them re-join the game and inform the town that the cult is dead.

Jedo 2 replaces DP.
mudbuck 3 replaces jadesmar, who had previously replaced Nanook.

As day dawns, the bachelors look around.
"Hey, we all seem to be alive!" says one bachelor.
"Are we? Let me count. One, two... Hey, yeah, we are all still alive!" confirms another.
"That's odd, no one died."
"I wouldn't be so sure of that..." says yet another bachelor, peering around the screen. "I don't think the darling bachelorette made it. She was so pretty, too..."

Indeed, she did not make it through the night. The lovely bachelorette Mgm was killed in the night by a single gunshot wound right between her pretty little eyes. She was such a good listener.

'Tis day 7! 5 alive, 3 to lynch!

[Jedo the Jedi]

It is indeed true that I am replacing DP. I don't have time to reread the thread right now, probably not even until Sunday evening, but when I get the chance, I will reread then post my assessment of the situation. You don't have to wait up for me.

[mudbuck]

The game is really thinning out. At five people and two(?) mafia dead, I conclude there is only one mafia left. The town chance of winning is approximately 47% at only one mafia.

Sorry if I sound a bit obvious. I'm trying to get on track.
_________________
1000oclock.com

[ralphmerridew]

I move that Neo and mudbuck give their full roles, then Jedo finishes his claim, then Mackay and I give our full roles.

[Mgm]

Bah! Curse you scum! I hope the town will torture you in a slow and painful death!

[Jedo the Jedi]

Okay, I just finished reading the thread and might I say...WOW! A lot has gone on in this game. Now, for my assessment on the game.

1. FOS Neo. Nothing too strong, just his lurking.
2. FOS Mackay mostly for her vague suspicion throwing and for this:

[Mackay]

Jedo, you're kidding, right?

You might want to read my posts about MattV again.

Besides, if we were in it together, do you REALLY think any self-respecting mafia would launch an all-out attack against their GODFATHER?!

Raised Eyebrow of "well, that was stupid": Jedo

(btw, w00t! at getting the GF)

I had some suspicions yesterday, but I wanted to get MattV first. Let me read the last few pages and then post again.